Entertaining Beliefs in Economic Mobility by Eunji Kim

Full Article:


Discussion and Conclusion

What sustains belief in the prospect of upward economic mobility in an era with an “apocalyptic” level of

economic inequality? Social science literature points to an extensive list of historical factors unique to the

United States—such as the existence of the frontier or the Protestant work ethic—and concludes that the

belief in the American Dream is “just deeply embedded in American mythology...and myths last because

they are dreams fulfilled in our imaginations” (Hanson and White 2011, p.7; see also Hochschild 1996;

Huntington 1981; McCloskey and Zaller 1984; Kluegel and Smith 1986).

I argue that perceptions of economic mobility must be understood alongside the media discourse and

environment, just like any other studies of sociotropic economic perceptions. Unlike much of political

science scholarship, which assumes that the news media is the primary source of politically relevant infor-

mation, I highlight that the media content that Americans watch the most—entertainment media—offers

powerful exemplars of upward mobility and serves as an important source of information that affects peo-

ple’s beliefs in the American Dream. Using an array of different media data sources, this article confirms

the popularity and availability of TV programs that offer a vivid exemplars of ordinary, hard-working

Americans who are rewarded financially, and it uses both observational and experimental data to find

that exposure to rags-to-riches entertainment media increases people’s belief in the American Dream and

promotes internal attributions of wealth. These effects are mainly driven by Republicans and those who

are less interested in politics. Additional lab-in-the-field experiments shed light on the psychological

mechanism linking merit-focused narratives and redistributive policy preferences.

The duration of entertainment media effects—the possibility that these media effects fade away in after

a short time, and the duration of entertainment media effects—should be explored in future studies. In

the meantime, the methodological advantages of focusing on shared rags-to-riches narratives are clear,

because these messages remain the same across different episodes and programs. If anything, the sheer

availability and popularity of these programs alleviate concerns for external validity. Even if the public’s

taste for shows that feature ordinary Americans dissipates, the challenges of producing high-cost scripted

shows in a fragmented media market have resulted in a trend in which the vast majority of cable TV shows

are expected to continue featuring ordinary Americans (Ralph Bunche Center 2015; VanDerWerff 2016).

For the same financial reasons, streaming services such as Netflix, Amazon, and HBO now produce their

own reality programs that have a similar rags-to-riches narrative (e.g., Making the Cut (Amazon), Next in

Fashion (Netflix)).

My results underscore the overdue need to expand the scope of political communication and public

opinion research beyond news. The mass media has long been known to influence citizens’ sociotropic

perceptions, but mainstream social science research usually equates mass media with news media. Despite

dramatic changes in the media environment, the scholarly focus on news has remained intact. The most

prominent works of political communication in recent years confirm a focus on traditionally defined “po-

litical” aspects. Scholars have richly documented the political consequences of dwindling news audiences

(Prior 2007), declining confidence in the press (Ladd 2011), partisan media consumption (Arceneaux and

Johnson 2013; Levendusky 2013), the nationalization of local news media (Hopkins 2018), social media

platform (Settle 2018), and fake news (Guess, Nyhan and Reifler 2020) among other considerations. The

realm of soft news seems to be the farthest afield that quantitative academics have looked (Baum 2011;

Young 2019).

Though behavioral evidence suggests that most Americans tune out the news (Bakshy, Messing and

Adamic 2015; Flaxman, Goel and Rao 2016; see also Guess 2020), very little attention has been paid to

what political content is present in what they are watching instead. Entertainment media is still viewed as

“at best a distraction from politics and at worst a cause of active disengagement” (p. 852) and is deemed

worthy of studying only when it affects ostensibly political variables (Delli Carpini 2014). As long as

economic perceptions are central to the study of politics, however, this entire category of non-political

programs that affect such perceptions can no longer be dismissed. Furthermore, studying entertainment

media consumption may provide answers to many questions about distortions and biases in public opin-

ion. Widespread American misperceptions about the criminal justice system or policing power, for in-

stance, could be better understood if we account for the fact that America’s widely popular network TV

shows have consistently been crime series such as NCIS and Criminal Minds (Byers and Johnson 2009;

Cole and Dioso-Villa 2006).

My findings also inform broader discussions of public attitudes toward redistributive democracy. Un-

dergirding long-standing economic theories of redistribution is an assumption that citizens will favor

more generous levels of redistribution if they recognize an unfair economic system. This has been repeat-

edly proven to hold in experimental settings in which people are forced to consume pessimistic, news-like

economic information on rising income inequality or declining mobility (Alesina, Stantcheva and Teso

2018). Yet across different observational data, scholars have been puzzled to find that citizens are generally

moving away from more egalitarian policy preferences as the income gap widens (Ashok, Kuziemko and

Washington 2016; Kenworthy and McCall 2008; Kelly and Enns 2010; But see also Franko 2016; Newman

2020). This seeming paradox can be resolved if we take into account the fact that Americans are reportedly

watching four hours of television every day (Koblin 2016) and are receiving distorted information about

upward mobility. Belief in economic mobility can powerfully legitimize wealth disparity (Corak 2013;

Kluegel and Smith 1986; Shariff, Wiwad and Aknin 2016), and scholars of class and inequality should

recognize that non-political mass media cultivate foundational aspects of American politics, such as the

beliefs in economic freedom and individualism. If American exceptionalism includes the persistent ad-

herence to egalitarianism, self-determination, and laissez-faire economics, it is important to remember

that the United States consumes more TV than any other developed economy (OECD 2013).

In the Gilded Age of the late 19th century, Americans read Horatio Alger’s rags-to-riches dime novels.

Today, their counterparts in the new Gilded Age are browsing through hundreds of channels saturated

with rags-to-riches entertainment programs, and have elected the former host of The Apprentice as the

head of state. In this era of choice, entertainment media content is what appeals to citizens, as lowbrow as

it may seem; the political consequences, however, are anything but trivial.

The Left is full of Groomers! Unlike Us Republicans

the left is full of groomers! unlike us republicans 😏

Republican anti-abortion activist Howard Scott Heldreth is a convicted child rapist in Florida.
Republican County Commissioner David Swartz pleaded guilty to molesting two girls under the age of 11 and was sentenced to 8 years in prison.
Republican judge Mark Pazuhanich pleaded no contest to fondling a 10-year old girl and was sentenced to 10 years probation.
Republican anti-abortion activist Nicholas Morency pleaded guilty to possessing child pornography on his computer and offering a bounty to anybody who murders an abortion doctor.
Republican legislator Edison Misla Aldarondo was sentenced to 10 years in prison for raping his daughter between the ages of 9 and 17.
Republican Mayor Philip Giordano is serving a 37-year sentence in federal prison for sexually abusing 8- and 10-year old girls.
Republican campaign consultant Tom Shortridge was sentenced to three years probation for taking nude photographs of a 15-year old girl.
Republican racist pedophile and United States Senator Strom Thurmond had sex with a 15-year old black girl whohe married after she produced a child.
Republican pastor Mike Hintz, whom George W. Bush commended during the 2004 presidential campaign, surrendered to police after admitting to a sexual affair with a female juvenile.
Republican legislator Peter Dibble pleaded no contest to having an inappropriate relationship with a 13-year-old girl.
Republican activist Lawrence E. King, Jr. organized child sex parties at the White House during the 1980s.
Republican lobbyist Craig J. Spence organized child sex parties at the White House during the 1980s.
Republican Congressman Dinald "Buz" Lukens was found guilty of having sex with a female minor and sentenced to one month in jail.
Republican fundraiser Richard A. Delgaudio was found guilty of child porn charges and paying two teenage girls to pose for sexual photos.
Republican activist Mark A. Grethen convicted on six counts of sex crimes involving children.
Republican activist Randal David Ankeney pleaded guilty to attempted sexual assault on a child.
Republican Congressman Dan Crane had sex with a female minor working as a congressional page.
Republican activist and Christian Coalition leader Beverly Russell admitted to an incestuous relationship with his step daughter.
Republican governor Arnold Schwarzenegger allegedly had sex with a 16 year old girl when he was 28.
Republican congressman and anti-gay activist Robert Bauman was charged with having sex with a 16-year-old boy he picked up at a gay bar.
Republican Committee Chairman Jeffrey Patti was arrested for distributing a video clip of a 5-year-old girl being raped.
Republican activist Marty Glickman (a.k.a. "Republican Marty"), was taken into custody by Florida police on four counts of unlawful sexual activity with an underage girl and one count of delivering the drug LSD.
Republican legislative aide Howard L. Brooks was charged with molesting a 12-year old boy and possession of child pornography.
Republican Senate candidate John Hathaway was accused of having sex with his 12-year old baby sitter and withdrew his candidacy after the allegations were reported in the media.
Republican preacher Stephen White, who demanded a return to traditional values, was sentenced to jail after offering $20 to a 14-year-old boy for permission to perform oral sex on him.
Republican talk show host Jon Matthews pleaded guilty to exposing his genitals to an 11 year old girl.
Republican anti-gay activist Earl "Butch" Kimmerling was sentenced to 40 years in prison for molesting an 8-year old girl after he attempted to stop a gay couple from adopting her.
Republican Party leader Paul Ingram pleaded guilty to six counts of raping his daughters and served 14 years in federal prison.
Republican election board official Kevin Coan was sentenced to two years probation for soliciting sex over the internet from a 14-year old girl.
Republican politician Andrew Buhr was charged with two counts of first degree sodomy with a 13-year old boy.
Republican politician Keith Westmoreland was arrested on seven felony counts of lewd and lascivious exhibition to girls under the age of 16 (i.e. exposing himself to children).
Republican anti-abortion activist John Allen Burt was charged with sexual misconduct involving a 15-year old girl.
Republican County Councilman Keola Childs pleaded guilty to molesting a male child.
Republican activist John Butler was charged with criminal sexual assault on a teenage girl.
Republican candidate Richard Gardner admitted to molesting his two daughters.
Republican Councilman and former Marine Jack W. Gardner was convicted of molesting a 13-year old girl.
Republican County Commissioner Merrill Robert Barter pleaded guilty to unlawful sexual contact and assault on a teenage boy.
Republican City Councilman Fred C. Smeltzer, Jr. pleaded no contest to raping a 15 year-old girl and served 6-months in prison.
Republican activist Parker J. Bena pleaded guilty to possession of child pornography on his home computer and was sentenced to 30 months in federal prison and fined $18,000.
Republican parole board officer and former Colorado state representative, Larry Jack Schwarz, was fired after child pornography was found in his possession.
Republican strategist and Citadel Military College graduate Robin Vanderwall was convicted in Virginia on five counts of soliciting sex from boys and girls over the internet.
Republican city councilman Mark Harris, who is described as a "good military man" and "church goer," was convicted of repeatedly having sex with an 11-year-old girl and sentenced to 12 years in prison.
Republican businessman Jon Grunseth withdrew his candidacy for Minnesota governor after allegations surfaced that he went swimming in the nude with four underage girls, including his daughter.
Republican director of the "Young Republican Federation" Nicholas Elizondo molested his 6-year old daughter and was sentenced to six years in prison.
Republican benefactor of conservative Christian groups, Richard A. Dasen Sr., was charged with rape for allegedly paying a 15-year old girl for sex. Dasen, 62, who is married with grown children and several grandchildren, has allegedly told police that over the past decade he paid more than $1 million to have sex with a large number of young women.

Posted by Redditor: https://www.reddit.com/user/_sirmemesalot_/